web space | free hosting | Business WebSite Hosting | Free Website Submission | shopping cart | php hosting


Criminal Abortion: Rose Lipner
Another example of the trickiness of hiding the body from a criminal abortion death
 Explore This Site
  Related Resources
• Abortion History
• Abortion Mortality
• Abortion Practice Before Legalization
• Abortionists of the 20th Century
• Accupuncture Abortionist Charged for Injuries
• Coathanger Abortions vs Safe-n-Legal Abortions
• Safe-n-Legal or Back-Alley Butchery?
• The Truth of Pre-Roe Abortion Mortality
• Women Killed by Abortion
 Abortion Mortality
• Anesthesia Deaths
• California Saline Deaths 1970-72
• Embolism Deaths
• Fatal Instillation Abortions
• Hemorrhage Deaths
• Illegal Abortions by Amateurs
• Illegal Abortions by Paramedical People
• Illegal Abortions by Physicians
• Instillation Deaths
• LDI Tombstone Project Deaths
• LDI Tombstone Project Deaths by State
• LDI Tombstone Project Deaths by Year
• National Abortion Federation Deaths
• New York Saline Deaths 1970-72
• Pre-Roe Abortion Deaths
• Post-Roe Illegal Abortions
• Pre-Roe Legal Abortions
• Self-Induced Abortion Deaths
• Teens Killed by Abortion
• Undiagnosed Ectopic Deaths
 Other Illegal Abortion Deaths
• Anna Anderson
• Olive Ash
• Doris Becker
• Kerneda Bennett
• Hughretta Binkley
• Cora Burke
• Amelia Cardito
• Joyce Chorney
• Helen Clark
• Virginia Clark
• Alice Corbett
• Isabell Cuda
• Lena Dakota
• Mary Davies
• Katherine DiDonato
• Ilene Eagen
• Beatrice Fisher
• Laura France
• Anna Gosch
• Edith Green
• Jolene Griffith
• Barbara Hanson
• Arretta Hardesty
• Kris Humphrey
• Rosie Jiminez
• Anna Johnson
• Joyce Johnson
• Joy Joy
• Alice Kimberly
• Mary Kirkpatrick
• Betty Ladel
• Harriet Larocque
• Asunta La Rosa
• Harriet Lichtenberg
• Barbara Lofrumento
• Dorothy Martin
• Lillian McCullough
• Madeline McGeehan
• Cleo Moore
• Viola Parr
• Agnes Pearson
• Magdalena Philippi
• Gertrude Pinsky
• Gene Raligh
• Virginia Rappe
• "Daisy" Roe
• "Helen" Roe
• "Nina" Roe
• "Patsy" Roe
• Jane Roe of 1937
• Jane Roe of Long Beach
• Florence Schnoor
• Rita Shea
• Geraldine Santoro
• Dorothy Schultz
• Jacqueline Smith
• Eliza Sowers
• Eva Swan
• Iva Triplett
• Jane Ward
• Nancy Ward
• Virginia Watson
• Ruth Weir
• Irene Wengel
• Loretta Wilson
• Grace Wolf
• Elvira Woodward
• Gertrude Wynants
• 1932: A String of Deaths in Oklahoma City
• Chicago, 1928: Abortionist Sentenced to Die
• Criminal Abortion Deaths Uncovered
• Doctors and the Back-Alley Abortion
 Legal Abortion Deaths Before Roe
• Cassandra Bleavins
• Twila Coulter
• Margaret Davis
• Gwendolyn Drummer
• Janet Forster
• Doris Grant
• Betty Hines
• Denise Holmes
• Sara Lint
• Natalie Meyers
• Katherine Morse
• Maria Ortega
• Erica Peterson
• "Amanda" Roe
• "Alice" Roe
• "Amy" Roe
• "Annie" Roe
• "Andrea" Roe
• "Anita" Roe
• "April" Roe
• "Audrey" Roe
• "Barbara" Roe
• "Beth" Roe
• "Connie" Roe
• "Danielle" Roe
• "Judy" Roe
• "Julie" Roe
• "Kimberly" Roe
• "Monica" Roe
• "Robin" Roe
• "Roseann" Roe
• "Roxanne" Roe
• "Sandra" Roe
• "Sheryl" Roe
• "Tammy" Roe
• "Vicki" Roe
• LaSandra Russ
• F.S.
• Stella Saenz
• Carole Schaner
• Margaret Smith
• Kathryn Strong
• Cheryl Vosseler

It's not easy to hide the body when you kill somebody during the commission of a crime, as many a criminal has discovered. This was true when the crime was an illegal abortion.

Those who scoff at the idea that the authorities could uncover even a fraction of criminal abortion deaths should reflect on cases such as the death of Rose Lipner, a 32-year-old mother of two.

Rose died at Riverdale (maternity) Hospital on January 29, 1936. Dr. Maxwell C. Katz, who both operated and lived at Riverdale, signed a death certificate indicating that Rose had died of complications of surgery he'd performed to treat a tumor.

After the funeral, an anonymous caller notified the police that Rose's death was suspicious. Based on this anonymous call, the authorities had Rose's body exhumed, and an autopsy was performed.

The medical examiner discovered that Rose had died not from surgery for a tumor, but from an illegal abortion.

Katz was arraigned for second-degree manslaughter in Rose's death.

This dynamic is so important it bears repeating:

Now that abortion is a "right" rather than a crime, a woman's death is no longer a criminal matter. There is nobody -- not the medical board, not hospital accreditation boards, not maternal mortality committees, not the police -- that will go prying about based on a report that a woman's death was actually due to an abortion. Abortion deaths are purely a civil matter. And even if the family sues, the case gets publicity, and the death is openly known to be an abortion death, the Centers for Disease Control no longer have any interest in counting it. (See the case of Latachie Veal).

Roe vs. Wade decreased the chances that a woman's abortion death will be noticed, investigated, and counted, by making it a private matter the authorities have no cause to involve themselves with. And until we fully grasp this fact, our thinking about abortion mortality statistics will be based on false premises.

One more note: Rose's abortion was typical of pre-Roe abortions in that it was performed by a physician.

Source: New York Times 2-8-36

Visit the RealChoice blog

Previous articles

Like this link graphic? Click here to learn how to add it to your web page.

Search this site powered by FreeFind
View the Cemetery of Choice Calendar
Free Calendar from Free Calendar from

Send me your feedback!


Cemetery of Choice

RealChoice Blog

Not Just the Unborn