Ignorance and Mushrooms Grow Best In the Dark
I taped that conversation with Susan Shapiro of NAF on October 19, 1995, while I was doing research for Lime 5. What Ms. Shapiro evidently didn't know is that I'd taped another very interesting conversation with one of their referral hotline counselors just the previous day. Posing as a woman scheduled for an abortion at Edward Allred's Albany clinic in Chicago, I expressed misgivings. I said that I'd heard of a patient death there. The counselor had assured me, "All of the complications are reported here, and if there was an excessive amount of complications, they would not be a member of the National Abortion Federation." She described Albany's abortionist, Steve Lichtenberg, as, "a very, very excellent doctor, very well respected." She dismissed the death as "just a rumor."
Screen capture of assurance of safe, quality care on National Abortion Federation web site. It reads: "What is a NAF Clinic? NAF is the professional association of abortion providers in North America. .... In order to become a member, a clinic must complete a rigorous application process. Member clinics have agreed to comply with our standards for quality and care.... NAF periodically conducts site visits to confirm that our clinics are in compliance with our guidelines.
I called back later and told the counselor that someone had told me to ask about Deanna Bell. (Thirteen-year-old Deanna had died at Albany after an abortion by Lichtenberg.) The counsellor put me on hold, then came back and said that I was confused, that I was thinking of Becky Bell. Becky, the counselor told me, had died from "an illegal abortion. She hadn't called the National Abortion Federation. She obviously did not go to a NAF member." I insisted that I had the girl's name correct -- it was Deanna, not Becky -- and that the abortion had been at Albany. The counselor was adamant. Whoever had told me that someone named Deanna Bell had died after an abortion at Albany "might be an anti-choice person."
There is no doubt in my mind that the counsellor was shocked and confused when I could put a name to the rumored dead girl. As I sat on hold, I imagined the counselor seeking information, wanting to know if the story of Deanna's death was true. And I imagine that somebody said to her, "She must be thinking of Becky Bell." (Becky Bell had been the furthest thing from my mind; I'd chosen the Deanna Bell case because Albany was part of Family Planning Associates Medical Group, NAF's flagship chain of abortion clinics, and because Lichtenberg is a high-profile member who often trains his fellow abortionists at NAF Risk Management Seminars). I believe that Susan Shapiro was telling the truth when she said that NAF didn't give hotline counselors information on malpractice and death at NAF clinics. After all, it is easier to get people to sell a product they believe in.
It is also entirely possible that whoever the counselor consulted was equally in the dark about Deanna Bell's fatal encounter with Steve Lichtenberg. After Deanna's death, Albany sent a thank-you letter, signed by Lichtenberg, to the hospital that had referred Deanna to them, describing her abortion as "uneventful." Either abortion deaths are so common as to be unworthy of comment, or Lichtenberg and his staff were hoping that they could send a 13-year-old girl out under a sheet without anybody noticing.
Some more examples of problems that aren't "serious problems":
Some more examples of complications that weren't "serious":
The converasations quoted here are cited in Lime 5 by Mark Crutcher, copyright 1996 Life Dynamics Inc.
Related Links -- Becky Bell:
Related Links -- Deanna Bell:
Like this link graphic? Click here to learn how to add it to your web page.
More on NAF
A Few Bad Apples
About Those NAF Clinics in Kentucky
Abu Hayat, Erstwhile NAF Member
Bruce Steir, Active With NAF
BUSTED! Planned Parenthood and National Abortion Federation Caught in Pedophile Protection Scandal
Charity Navigator Report on NAF
Ignorance and Mushrooms Grow Best in the Dark
NAF and NRL Collide
NAF Member Eastern Women's Center
NAF Member Midtown Hospital
NAF NewSpeak on Abortion Pill
National Abortion Federation
National Abortion Federation Deaths
On the Use of Human Shields
Ronachai Banchongmanie, Erstwhile NAF Member
Social Worker Takes Girl from Alaska to Seattle for Secret Abortion
Steir and NAF in Perspective
Steve Lichtenberg and FPA
Who Do You Believe?
Angela Scott and Deloris Smith
Food for Thought
Botched Abortion Leads to Amputation
LDI and the CDC
Misplaced Priorities Cost Women's Lives
Unequal Burden on the Poor?
The Bad Old Days of Abortion
Who's Putting the Unborn Ahead of the Born?
A Mother's Nightmare
Do Rape Victims Really Need Abortions?
What's the Need for Abortion?
Your Bedroom, the Government, and Abortion Laws
Is Childbirth Safety Relevant to Abortion?
When the POC Really is Just Tissue
Is 'Who Decides?' Really the Question?
Stress and the Abortion Decision
Coathanger Abortion: Powerful image, but how true to life?
Unplanned Pregnancies that Worked Out
Fetal Diagnoses Leading to Unnecessary Abortions
Who is the Enemy?
Did I Deserve the Death Penaltyh
Is This the Face of the Enemy?
Another Anti-Choice Fanatic
Abortion, Law, and Real Choice
Women's Rights are Common Ground
The Abortion War and Communication
What Real Informed Consent Would Look Like
Diane Sawyer and the Non-Story of Lawson Akpulonu
Women Who Change Their Minds After the Abortion
Comparative Safety - Abortion & Stuff Folks Get Riled About
Where's the Pro Choice Movement on Elective Amputations?
Unintended Late Abortions
19th Century Abortion Cases and Other Self-Injury
Are Abortions Used as Birth Control?
Pro Child/Pro Choice Rings Hollow
The "Koop Report" on Abortion
What's "Adequate Access" to Abortion?
Abortion, Suffering, and the Chinese Widow
Freaks Teaches Pro-Life Lesson